Telling the Story of Blackwell’s Island

I wrote a book about Blackwell’s Island (what Roosevelt Island was called in the 19th century) called Damnation Island. This was the period when the island was owned by the city and they used it to build and run a lunatic asylum, a couple of prisons, and hospitals for the poor. I’ve been thinking about Blackwell’s Island again because I recently recorded a podcast for the Gotham Center (the whole series is great, in my opinion, and well worth listening to). I also think about it from time to time because we keep making the same mistakes repeatedly. Films made of asylums 100 years later for instance, are horrifying. I recorded Titicut Follies, a 1967 documentary about the Bridgewater State Hospital for the criminally insane, but I can’t bring myself to watch it.

This quote captures just how bad it was on Blackwell’s Island. What breaks my heart is that as awful as it was then, life inside many replacement institutions today is worse. The picture below is of the Workhouse, one of the prisons on the island.

“When you pass down in a boat along Blackwell’s Island and see its greensward and leafy trees, and massive monumental buildings, perhaps you may think it a fine place to live in, but under those roofs a great amount of misery, sin and shame is hidden, from which in many instances death is the only relief. And years come and years go, but the misery ever remains the same. Many a one who started in life with bright hopes, is carried away from here to an unknown grave in Potter’s Filed.”

— Rev. Samuel II. Frisbie, S.J. Woodstock Letters, Volume XXIII, Number 1, April 1, 1894

Stacy Horn

I've written six non-fiction books, the most recent is Damnation Island: Poor, Sick, Mad, and Criminal in 19th-Century New York.

View all posts by Stacy Horn →

2 thoughts on “Telling the Story of Blackwell’s Island

  1. Yeah, I don’t get it. Thank you for shedding light on these places of “misery” for the poor souls there. Progress moves at a snail’s pace I guess. This country needs more Beto O’Rourke’s in it.

  2. America in the 19th century, I don’t know. You read about how great America is and all I see is we got off to a bad start and kept getting worse and worse. the 19th century was a nightmare of doing terrible things. We don’t do the right thing unless there’s a law instructing us that we have to. The 21st century seems to be all about repealing the laws we made in the late 19th and 20th centuries.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *